- Beverly Matthews, July 20, 2025 to present (Certified Lay Minister)
- Terry McDorman – 2022 to June 30, 2025
- April Patek — 2020 to 2022
- Matt Stevens — 2016 to 2020
- Janet Eggleston — 2012 to 2016
- Ken Harris — 2009 to 2012
- David Hutton — 2002 to 2009
- Peter Wehrly — 1996 to 2002
- James Mahffey — 1993 to 1996
- Walter Carlson — 1990 to 1993
- Ernestferd Lang — 1983 to 1990
- Oral Landis — 1982 to 1983
- Wayne Fyffe — 1980 to 1981
- Perry Bishop — 1973 to 1979
- Bluford Dawson — 1971 to 1973
- Louis Arkema — 1965 to 1971
- Donald Mann — 1963 to 1965
- Darrell Montgomery — 1959 to 1963
- Lowell White — 1957 to 1959
- Lloyd Vinnage — 1955 to 1957
- Carl Hass — 1951 to 1954
- C Gideon Carlson — 1947 to 1950
- James Organ — 1946 (Jan to June)
- Henry Munch — 1943 to 1946
- C. W. Ivie — 1939 to 1943
- Francis Smith — 1936 to 1938
- Lewis Hopper — 1935
- Jas. T Wilson — 1933 to 1934
- David A Bloomster — 1932
- R. J. Wroughton — 1927 to 1931
- Dr John Detcher — 1927
- C. W. Gant — 1925 – 1926
- S. N. Madden — 1923 to 1924
- O. C. Clapper — 1920 to 1922
- J. S. Dundas — 1917 to 1919
- C. W. Hammand — 1914 to 1916
- R. S. Hubbard — 1913
- F. W. Ward — 1911 to 1912
- J. B. Pawson — 1909 to 1910
- Dr. H. H. Oneal — 1907 to 1908
- W. T. Beadles — 1906
- M. N. English — 1904 to 1905
- Lewis Campbell – 1903
- E. M. Sutton — 1901 to 1903
- E. J. Durham — 1988 to 1901
- Anthus Willard — 1895 to 1898
- J. W. Eckman — 1892 to 1894
- Melchair Aver — 1891
- F. T. Sprvill — 1889-1890
- J. R. Reasoner — 1886 to 1888
- C. G. Wood — 1885
- S. E. Whitlock — 1882 to 1884
- D. E. May — 1879 to 1881
- John Colwell — 1876 to 1878
- Jonas Dimmit — 1875
- P. C. Carroll — 1873 to 1874
- I Villars — 1871 to 1872
- Leonard Smith — 1869 to 1870
- I Barber — 1868
- A semple — 1867
- Peter Wallace — 1864 to 1866
- J Nottingham — 1863
- Jos Lane — 1863
- W. R. Howard — 1862
- J. M. Lane — 1861
- S. S. Russell — 1860
- Thos. Allinson — 1859
Macon United Methodist Church 